Trends in Molecular Medicine
Volume 26, Issue 7, July 2020, Pages 683-697
第 26 卷第 7 期,2020 年 7 月,第 683-697 页
Journal home page for Trends in Molecular Medicine

Review  综述
Haptoglobin Therapeutics and Compartmentalization of Cell-Free Hemoglobin Toxicity
触珠蛋白疗法与游离血红蛋白毒性的区室化作用

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molmed.2020.02.004Get rights and content  获取权限和内容
Full text access  全文访问

Highlights  重点内容

  • Lysis of red blood cells in the circulation or within confined anatomical spaces accompanies many disease conditions.
    循环系统或特定解剖空间内的红细胞溶解伴随多种疾病状态发生。
  • Translocation of hemoglobin dimers across tissue barriers is the key initiation step of Hb toxicity, which facilitates chemical Hb reactions in vulnerable tissue compartments.
    血红蛋白二聚体跨组织屏障的转移是血红蛋白毒性的关键起始步骤,这会促进脆弱组织区间内的血红蛋白化学反应。
  • The biochemical drivers of Hb toxicity are oxidative reactions and reactions that consume the vasodilator nitric oxide, causing vasoconstriction.
    血红蛋白毒性的生化驱动因素是氧化反应以及消耗血管舒张剂一氧化氮的反应,从而导致血管收缩。
  • Haptoglobin binds Hb-dimers within a complex too large to translocate across tissue barriers. An auxiliary function of the Hb–haptoglobin complex changes the structural conformation of the heme-pocket, blocking heme release and providing antioxidative protection.
    触珠蛋白与血红蛋白二聚体结合形成的复合物体积过大,无法跨组织屏障转运。血红蛋白-触珠蛋白复合物的辅助功能改变了血红素口袋的构象,阻止血红素释放并提供抗氧化保护。
  • Haptoglobin compartmentalization of cell-free Hb provides opportunities for drug development in disease areas such as sickle cell anemia, sepsis, blood transfusion, and subarachnoid hemorrhage.
    触珠蛋白对游离血红蛋白的区室化作用为镰状细胞贫血、脓毒症、输血和蛛网膜下腔出血等疾病领域的药物研发提供了机遇。
Hemolysis and accumulation of cell-free hemoglobin (Hb) in the circulation or in confined tissue compartments such as the subarachnoid space is an important driver of disease. Haptoglobin is the Hb binding and clearance protein in human plasma and an efficient antagonist of Hb toxicity resulting from physiological red blood cell turnover. However, endogenous concentrations of haptoglobin are insufficient to provide protection against Hb-driven disease processes in conditions such as sickle cell anemia, sepsis, transfusion reactions, medical-device associated hemolysis, or after a subarachnoid hemorrhage. As a result, there is increasing interest in developing haptoglobin therapeutics to target ‘toxic’ cell-free Hb exposures. Here, we discuss key concepts of Hb toxicity and provide a perspective on the use of haptoglobin as a therapeutic protein.
溶血和游离血红蛋白(Hb)在循环系统或蛛网膜下腔等封闭组织间隙中的积聚是疾病发展的重要驱动因素。结合珠蛋白是人体血浆中负责结合和清除血红蛋白的蛋白质,能有效拮抗生理性红细胞更新所产生的血红蛋白毒性。然而,在内源性结合珠蛋白浓度不足的情况下(如镰状细胞贫血、脓毒症、输血反应、医疗器械相关溶血或蛛网膜下腔出血后),无法为血红蛋白驱动的疾病进程提供保护。因此,开发靶向"毒性"游离血红蛋白暴露的结合珠蛋白疗法日益受到关注。本文讨论了血红蛋白毒性的关键概念,并对结合珠蛋白作为治疗性蛋白质的应用前景进行了展望。

Keywords  关键词

hemoglobin
haptoglobin
heme
hemolysis
sepsis
transfusion
sickle cell disease
subarachnoid hemorrhage

血红蛋白触珠蛋白血红素溶血脓毒症输血镰状细胞病蛛网膜下腔出血

Haptoglobin: The Natural Antagonist of Hemoglobin Toxicity
触珠蛋白:血红蛋白毒性的天然拮抗剂

Haptoglobin (gene symbol HP) is the hemoglobin (Hb) binding protein in humans and most mammals. It was described in 1946 as an acute phase plasma glycoprotein that bound Hb and enhanced its peroxidative activity [1]. The interest in haptoglobin has surged more recently with the observation that the protein is a very efficient antagonist of Hb-toxicity in various disease models, including sickle cell disease (SCD) (see Glossary), transfusion, sepsis, and subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) (see Clinician's Corner). Haptoglobin can be purified in large quantities from pooled human plasma or produced by recombinant protein expression generating opportunities for new drug development [2]. Here, we will summarize key concepts of Hb toxicity and we will delineate the potential therapeutic use of haptoglobin in three exemplary disease conditions that are accelerated by a Hb-driven disease pathway.
触珠蛋白(基因符号 HP)是人类及大多数哺乳动物体内与血红蛋白(Hb)结合的蛋白质。1946 年研究发现,这种急性期血浆糖蛋白能与 Hb 结合并增强其过氧化活性[1]。近期研究观察到该蛋白在镰状细胞病(SCD)(见术语表)、输血、脓毒症和蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)(见临床要点)等多种疾病模型中能高效拮抗 Hb 毒性,使得触珠蛋白研究热度激增。触珠蛋白可从混合人血浆中大量纯化,或通过重组蛋白表达生产,这为新药开发提供了可能[2]。本文将概述 Hb 毒性的关键机制,并阐述触珠蛋白在三种典型 Hb 驱动病理进程加速的疾病中的潜在治疗应用。
Humans have distinct genes located on chromosome 16 denoted as HP1 (exons 1–5) and HP2 [exons 1–4 (3–4) 5]. The two alleles are the result of complex gene recombinations and deletions in human evolution [3]. HP2 contains an intragenic duplication of HP1 consisting of a 1.7-kb DNA fragment that repeats HP1 exons 3 and 4 [4]. This gene duplication occurred at some point during human evolution from primates [5,6]. The two human haptoglobin genes (HP1 and HP2), that result from this exon duplication encode for one of three primary haptoglobin phenotypes (Hp 1-1, Hp 2-1, and Hp 2-2) [7., 8., 9.]. All haptoglobin phenotypes are composed of the same Hb binding β subunit (Hpβ, 35 kDa), but different crosslinking α globin subunits (denoted Hpα1, 9 kDa, or Hpα2, 16 kDa) [9,10]. The α subunits are involved in intramolecular disulfide bonding and define internal contacts important for haptoglobin dimerization [10]. The structural consequences are determined by the number of cysteines available for disulfide bond formation resulting in dimeric (Hp 1-1, 89.1 kDa) or multimeric (Hp 2-1, 89.1–300 kDa; Hp 2-2, ~170–900 kDa) haptoglobin proteins, as determined by mass spectrometry [11]. For Hp 2-2, the tetrameric state with a molecular weight of 199.1 kDa appears to be the dominant association pathway [11]. Plasma concentrations in adults exist in a fairly broad range (0.3–1.9 mg/ml) and are dependent on individual genotypes that encode for protein subunits expressing plasma haptoglobin concentrations in the following order: Hp1-1 > Hp2-1 > Hp2-2 [12].
人类在 16 号染色体上存在两个独特基因,分别标记为 HP1(外显子 1-5)和 HP2[外显子 1-4(3-4)5]。这两个等位基因是人类进化过程中复杂基因重组与缺失的结果[3]。HP2 包含一段 1.7kb 的 HP1 基因内重复片段,该片段复制了 HP1 的外显子 3 和 4[4]。这种基因复制发生在人类从灵长类进化的某个阶段[5,6]。由此外显子复制产生的两个人类结合珠蛋白基因(HP1 和 HP2)编码三种主要结合珠蛋白表型(Hp 1-1、Hp 2-1 和 Hp 2-2)之一[7., 8., 9.]。所有结合珠蛋白表型均由相同的 Hb 结合β亚基(Hpβ,35 kDa)构成,但具有不同的交联α珠蛋白亚基(标记为 Hpα1,9 kDa 或 Hpα2,16 kDa)[9,10]。α亚基参与分子内二硫键形成,并决定结合珠蛋白二聚化的重要内部接触位点[10]。质谱分析表明,其结构差异取决于可用于二硫键形成的半胱氨酸数量,从而形成二聚体(Hp 1-1,89.1 kDa)或多聚体(Hp 2-1,89.1-300 kDa;Hp 2-2,~170-900 kDa)结合珠蛋白[11]。 对于 Hp 2-2 型结合珠蛋白,分子量为 199.1 kDa 的四聚体状态似乎是主要的结合途径[11]。成人血浆浓度存在较宽范围(0.3-1.9 mg/ml),其水平取决于编码蛋白亚基的个体基因型,表现为以下浓度梯度:Hp1-1 > Hp2-1 > Hp2-2[12]。
Understanding the role of haptoglobin as a therapeutic to combat Hb toxicity centers on the primary binding site for Hb dimers. The high-affinity and essentially irreversible binding between the haptoglobin β chain and the Hb αβ dimer, which occurs at a 1:1 stoichiometry, accounts for the three primary mechanisms of protection by sequestering the small Hb dimers in a large protein complex, by protecting key amino acids in Hb that are vulnerable to oxidation, and by stabilizing the globin-heme interaction [10,13., 14., 15., 16.]. Therefore, dosing of haptoglobin based on molar concentration of β subunits is critical to understanding the results from animal models and translation to humans. The greatest body of knowledge on haptoglobin dosing in massive transfusion, burn injury, and mechanical assist device-related hemolysis can be ascertained from the clinical use of haptoglobin in Japan. Although there are no reports from randomized clinical trials, available case reports and small patient series have been summarized in a review article [2]. In the USA and Europe, early stage drug development has focused on plasma-derived and recombinant sources of haptoglobin [2,17]. A summary of this work is provided herein, with a focus on a fundamental mechanism of the role of haptoglobin in attenuating Hb toxicity following hemolysis and the proof-of-concept disease models in which haptoglobin is being studied.
理解结合珠蛋白作为对抗血红蛋白毒性的治疗剂,其核心作用在于其与血红蛋白二聚体的主要结合位点。结合珠蛋白β链与血红蛋白αβ二聚体以 1:1 化学计量比形成的高亲和力且基本不可逆的结合,通过三种主要机制发挥保护作用:将小分子血红蛋白二聚体隔离在大型蛋白质复合物中、保护血红蛋白中易受氧化的关键氨基酸、以及稳定珠蛋白-血红素相互作用[10,13.,14.,15.,16.]。因此,基于β亚基摩尔浓度确定结合珠蛋白给药剂量,对于理解动物模型结果及向人体转化至关重要。关于大量输血、烧伤及机械辅助装置相关溶血情况下结合珠蛋白给药剂量的最全面知识,可参考日本临床应用数据。虽然目前尚无随机临床试验报告,但现有病例报告和小规模病例系列研究已在一篇综述文章中进行了总结[2]。在美国和欧洲,早期药物开发主要集中于血浆来源和重组来源的结合珠蛋白[2,17]。 本文概述了该研究工作的主要内容,重点探讨了触珠蛋白在溶血后减轻血红蛋白毒性作用的基本机制,以及目前正在研究触珠蛋白疗效的概念验证疾病模型。

Mechanisms of Hb and Heme Toxicity
血红蛋白与血红素的毒性机制

Typical disease conditions that are accelerated by cell-free Hb are the hemolytic anemias, where the primary site of cell-free Hb accumulation is in plasma. Other conditions, such as atherosclerosis with intraplaque hemorrhage and SAH, are characterized by extravascular hemolysis with cell-free Hb accumulation in tissues or within a defined space such as the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) compartment. Biological effects of Hb and its degradation products that yield adaptive effects or adverse ‘toxicity’ can be categorized according to a sequence of mechanisms: (i) decompartmentalization of Hb dimers across tissue barriers; (ii) reactions of Hb with nitric oxide (NO) and oxidative reactions; (iii) heme and iron release; and (iv) adaptive and pathophysiological effects. These mechanisms may be important contributors to tissue parenchymal injury in acute disease, medical procedures (transfusion and medical assist device use), and chronic genetic and acquired hemolytic anemia.
游离血红蛋白加速恶化的典型疾病包括溶血性贫血,其主要积累部位在血浆中。其他如伴有斑块内出血的动脉粥样硬化和蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)等病症,则以血管外溶血为特征,游离血红蛋白在组织或特定腔隙(如脑脊液腔室)中积聚。血红蛋白及其降解产物产生的适应性效应或有害"毒性"作用,可按以下机制序列进行分类:(i)血红蛋白二聚体跨组织屏障的区室化破坏;(ii)血红蛋白与一氧化氮(NO)的反应及氧化反应;(iii)血红素与铁的释放;(iv)适应性及病理生理学效应。这些机制可能是急性疾病、医疗操作(输血及医疗器械使用)以及慢性遗传性与获得性溶血性贫血中实质组织损伤的重要诱因。

Decompartmentalization  去区室化

Within red blood cells (RBCs), Hb exists as a stable tetramer (64 kD), consistent with its high concentration in the erythrocytes. When diluted within the plasma and extracellular spaces following hemolysis, Hb exists in a dynamic equilibrium of tetramer and αβ-subunit heterodimers. The αβ-dimers are of a relatively small molecular size (32 kD), allowing for protein translocation across tissue barriers such as the renal glomerulus, endothelial barriers in the myocardium and coronary arteries, as well as the different barriers between the CSF and the brain (e.g., the pia mater and ependymal cell layer) [18., 19., 20.]. The mechanisms responsible for Hb decompartmentalization vary depending on the tissue sites (e.g., kidney, brain, and heart). Decompartmentalization from the blood plasma across the glomerular filtration barrier defines the main pathway for cell-free Hb clearance from blood in the absence of haptoglobin. Tissue localized biochemical reactions of Hb and cast formation in the kidney can induce renal injury in animals and humans [18,21,22]. The sequelae of tissue exposure to Hb is most evident by reduced renal function and tubular injury following chronic low-level hemolysis or as overt hemoglobinuria following severe acute hemolysis [23,24]. Hb is also capable of entering the vascular structures and the lymph fluid after hemolysis [25]. However, the mechanisms associated with Hb decompartmentalization from blood plasma or perivascular sites (e.g., the Virchow-Robin space in the brain) into vascular structures or tissue parenchyma are not adequately understood. These processes may occur by transcellular transport or by intercellular trafficking, analogous to experimentally defined processes of albumin transport [26]. In-depth mechanistic definitions of this phenomenon are required for cell-free Hb and its prevention by haptoglobin binding.
在红细胞(RBCs)内,血红蛋白(Hb)以稳定的四聚体形式(64 kD)存在,这与红细胞内高浓度状态相符。当溶血后进入血浆和细胞外空间被稀释时,血红蛋白处于四聚体与αβ亚基异源二聚体的动态平衡中。αβ二聚体分子量相对较小(32 kD),能够穿越肾小球、心肌和冠状动脉的内皮屏障,以及脑脊液与大脑之间的多层屏障(如软脑膜和室管膜细胞层)[18,19,20]。导致血红蛋白去区室化的机制因组织部位(如肾脏、大脑和心脏)而异。在缺乏结合珠蛋白的情况下,血红蛋白从血浆跨越肾小球滤过屏障的去区室化过程构成了游离血红蛋白从血液中清除的主要途径。血红蛋白在组织局部的生化反应及肾脏管型形成可导致动物和人类出现肾损伤[18,21,22]。 组织暴露于血红蛋白(Hb)的后果在慢性低水平溶血后表现为肾功能下降和肾小管损伤,或在严重急性溶血后表现为明显血红蛋白尿[23,24]。溶血后 Hb 还能进入血管结构和淋巴液[25]。然而,关于 Hb 从血浆或血管周围部位(如大脑中的 Virchow-Robin 间隙)解区室化进入血管结构或实质组织的机制尚未充分阐明。这些过程可能通过跨细胞运输或细胞间运输发生,类似于实验定义的清蛋白运输过程[26]。针对游离 Hb 及其被触珠蛋白结合所阻止的现象,需要深入阐明其机制定义。

Hb, NO, and Pro-oxidant Reactions
血红蛋白、一氧化氮及促氧化反应

From a biochemical perspective, Hb-toxicity is determined by heme-iron oxidation and by the reaction of Hb with NO. Following the decompartmentalization of extracellular Hb from the vascular space into the subendothelial space and into smooth muscle layers of arteries, Hb reacts with NO, leading to reduced bioavailability of the vasodilator and, subsequently, systemic, pulmonary, and microvascular vasoconstriction [19,27]. NO depletion by extracellular Hb is a widely accepted hypothesis to explain the acute hypertensive response that occurs during hemolysis and is one mechanism for oxidation to ferric (Fe3+) Hb in tissue. NO depletion occurs via two well established reactions, NO dioxygenation (oxy-Hb) and iron nitrosylation (deoxy-Hb), [28]:
从生化角度来看,血红蛋白毒性取决于血红素铁的氧化及其与一氧化氮的反应。当血管外血红蛋白从血管腔室解离进入内皮下层和动脉平滑肌层后,会与一氧化氮发生反应,导致这种血管舒张剂的生物利用度降低,继而引发全身性、肺循环及微血管收缩[19,27]。细胞外血红蛋白消耗一氧化氮这一被广泛接受的假说,可解释溶血过程中出现的急性高血压反应,也是组织中血红蛋白氧化为三价铁(Fe 3+ )的机制之一。一氧化氮消耗通过两种明确反应实现:一氧化氮双加氧反应(氧合血红蛋白)和铁亚硝基化反应(脱氧血红蛋白)[28]:
  • NO dioxygenation: HbFe2+O2 + NO → Hb(Fe3+OONO•) → HbFe3+ + NO3
    一氧化氮双加氧反应:HbFe 2+ O 2 + NO → Hb(Fe 3+ OONO•) → HbFe 3+ + NO 3
  • Iron nitrosylation: HbFe2+ + NO → Hb(NO)
    铁亚硝基化反应:HbFe 2+ + NO → Hb(NO)
Under an excess concentration of NO over oxyHb (Fe2+), the absorbance changes of Hb measured by stopped-flow spectrophotometry can be fitted to the sum of three exponential reactions, supporting a previously suggested three-step reaction mechanism depicted in Box 1 (see Figure I in Box 1) [20,29,30]. This reaction pattern indicates that one Hb subunit monomer can react with three molecules of NO, suggesting that very low quantities of Hb within the vascular smooth muscle layer of an artery may cause significant vasodilator depletion and vasoconstriction.
当一氧化氮(NO)浓度超过氧合血红蛋白(Fe 2+ )时,通过停流分光光度法测得的血红蛋白吸光度变化可拟合为三个指数反应的总和,这支持了先前提出的三步反应机制(见框 1 中的图 I)[20,29,30]。该反应模式表明,一个血红蛋白亚基单体可与三分子 NO 发生反应,提示动脉血管平滑肌层中极微量的血红蛋白即可导致显著的血管舒张物质耗竭和血管收缩。
Box 1  框 1
Heme-Iron Oxidation and Nitric Oxide (NO) Reactions with Hemoglobin (Hb)
血红素铁氧化及一氧化氮(NO)与血红蛋白(Hb)的反应
  • (A)  (A)
    Autoxidation of oxy-Hb(Fe2+O2) results in the generation of Hb(Fe3+), which can release heme [146], particularly in the presence of a heme-acceptor compartment such as lipoproteins. Heme dissociation from tetrameric Hb primarily occurs from beta subunits and is reported to be ~1.5 h–1 at erythrocyte Hb concentrations (5 M, 330 g/l); following hemolysis and dimerization of Hb at low plasma/tissue concentrations, the rate of heme loss increases nearly tenfold to ~15 h–1 [146].
    氧合血红蛋白(Fe 2+ O 2 )的自氧化会生成 Hb(Fe 3+ ),后者可释放血红素[146],特别是在存在脂蛋白等血红素受体区室的情况下。四聚体血红蛋白中的血红素解离主要发生在β亚基,据报道在红细胞血红蛋白浓度(5 M,330 g/l)下解离时间约为 1.5 小时 –1 ;溶血后血红蛋白在低血浆/组织浓度下发生二聚化时,血红素丢失速率增加近十倍至约 15 小时 –1 [146]。
  • (B)
    The reactions of NO with Hb across a range of O2 liganded [oxy-Hb(Fe2+O2)] and nonliganded states [deoxy-Hb, Hb(Fe2+) and met-Hb, Hb(Fe3+)] are discussed extensively in the literature [28,30,147,148]. These reactions cause vasoconstriction by depleting the vasodilator [149]. Release of heme from met-Hb is a secondary toxic outcome of the NO reaction [150]. The illustrated reaction sequence that occurs in conditions of NO excess over Hb ultimately consumes three NO molecules per heme [20,29]. Consumption of the first NO in the process occurs rapidly, with a reported rate constant equal to 60–80 μM–1 s–1 [28,29,148] to produce Hb(Fe3+) and nitrate (NO3) as reaction products. At excess NO concentrations over heme, a second, slower NO consumption step reaction was reported [30] and is proposed to involve a series of reaction intermediates, beginning with a weakly associated NO–Hb(Fe3+) protein–ligand complex, which leads to a transient intermediate oxidation of NO and reduction of Hb(Fe3+) [NO+–Hb(Fe2+)], followed by reaction with water and production of nitrite (NO2), H+, and Hb(Fe2+). A third, and final, NO then rapidly binds to Hb(Fe2+) with a similar rate constant as the dioxygenation reaction (60–80 μM–1 s–1). Formation of a Hb–haptoglobin complex does not change the reaction kinetics across this whole sequence of NO reactions [20].
    一氧化氮(NO)与血红蛋白(Hb)在不同氧合状态下的反应机制在文献中已有广泛论述[28,30,147,148],包括氧合血红蛋白[oxy-Hb(Fe 2+ O 2 )]与非氧合状态[脱氧血红蛋白 deoxy-Hb、血红蛋白 Hb(Fe 2+ )及高铁血红蛋白 met-Hb, Hb(Fe 3+ )]。这些反应通过消耗血管舒张因子导致血管收缩[149]。高铁血红蛋白释放血红素是 NO 反应的次级毒性产物[150]。图示反应序列显示,当 NO 浓度超过血红蛋白时,每个血红素基团最终消耗三个 NO 分子[20,29]。 该过程中第一个 NO 的消耗反应迅速,报道的速率常数为 60-80μM –1 s –1 [28,29,148],反应产物为 Hb(Fe 3+ )和硝酸盐(NO 3 )。当 NO 浓度持续超过血红素时,文献报道存在第二个较慢的 NO 消耗步骤[30],该反应可能涉及一系列中间产物:首先形成弱结合的 NO-Hb(Fe 3+ )蛋白-配体复合物,继而产生 NO 的瞬时氧化中间体与 Hb(Fe 3+ )的还原态[NO + -Hb(Fe 2+ )],最终与水反应生成亚硝酸盐(NO 2 )、H + 及 Hb(Fe 2+ )。 第三个也是最后一个 NO 分子随即以与双氧合反应相似的速率常数(60-80 μM⁻¹s⁻¹)快速结合到 Hb(Fe²⁺)上。在整个 NO 反应序列中,血红蛋白-触珠蛋白复合物的形成并未改变这些反应动力学[20]。
Figure I
  1. Download: Download high-res image (344KB)
  2. Download: Download full-size image

Figure I. Hemoglobin (Hb) Autoxidation and Nitric Oxide (NO) Reactions.

Oxidation reactions that lead to higher oxidation states of Hb (i.e., HbFe4+) and redox cycling are dependent on the presence of supra-physiological concentrations of oxidants (e.g., lipid peroxides, R-OOH and hydrogen peroxide, H2O2) and differ based on the initial oxidation state of the heme-iron in Hb. These peroxidation reactions generate oxo-ferryl Hb (1) (HbFe4+=O) and transient radical species (2) (∙HbFe4+=O).
导致血红蛋白(Hb)氧化态升高(即 HbFe 4+ )和氧化还原循环的氧化反应依赖于超生理浓度氧化剂(如脂质过氧化物 R-OOH 和过氧化氢 H 2 O 2 )的存在,其反应进程会因血红素铁初始氧化态的不同而有所差异。这类过氧化反应会生成氧合正铁血红蛋白(1)(HbFe 4+ =O)及瞬态自由基(2)(∙HbFe 4+ =O)。

Peroxidation Reactions  过氧化反应

  • (1)
    HbFe2+O2 + H2O2 → HbFe4+ = O + H2O + O2
    HbFe 2+ O 2 + H 2 O 2 → HbFe 4+ =O + H 2 O + O 2
  • (2)
    HbFe3+ + H2O2 → ∙HbFe4+ = O + H2O
    HbFe 3+ + H 2 O 2 → ∙HbFe 4+ =O + H 2 O
These oxidative reactions may be an important determinant of Hb toxicity based on observations that superoxide and peroxide are formed and released into the extracellular spaces during inflammation and ischemia-reperfusion [31]. The predominant oxidized Hb species that can be detected and quantified in vivo are ferric Hb (HbFe3+) and hemichrome, a structurally distorted form of HbFe3+, and ferryl Hb (HbFe4+). Detection and quantitation of HbFe4+ and its radical in tissue and in the circulation requires specialized techniques [e.g., electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectrometry] and low temperatures, due to transient stability of the radical.
这些氧化反应可能是血红蛋白毒性的重要决定因素,基于观察到在炎症和缺血-再灌注过程中会形成超氧化物和过氧化物并释放到细胞外间隙[31]。在体内可检测和定量的主要氧化血红蛋白种类包括高铁血红蛋白(HbFe 3+ )、血色原(一种结构变形的 HbFe 3+ )以及亚铁血红蛋白(HbFe 4+ )。由于自由基的短暂稳定性,检测和定量组织及循环系统中的 HbFe 4+ 及其自由基需要特殊技术[如电子顺磁共振(EPR)光谱法]和低温条件。

Heme Release and Transfer
血红素释放与转移

A third mechanism by which Hb toxicity occurs is through release of heme from HbFe3+ [28]. This allows for the transfer of the lipophilic metallo-porphyrin to cell membrane components, soluble plasma proteins, cell surface receptors, and lipids, particularly low-density lipoprotein (LDL) and high-density lipoprotein (HDL) [32., 33., 34.]. The ultimate binding protein for free heme is hemopexin (Hpx), which irreversibly binds heme in a hexacoordinated complex, blocking its oxidative reactivity and delivering it to liver parenchymal cells for degradation [35]. Several proteins with lower heme-binding affinity exist as intermediate heme-carriers in plasma, such as albumin and alpha-1-microglobulin (A1M) [36., 37., 38.], while the small 27-kDa A1M is also a relevant tissue-binding protein for heme [36]. These proteins may modulate heme-distribution between plasma and different tissue compartments and could contribute toward organ-specific toxicity patterns when Hpx is depleted, such as in patients with SCD [39].
血红蛋白毒性的第三种作用机制是通过 HbFe 3+ 释放血红素[28]。这使得这种亲脂性金属卟啉能够转移至细胞膜组分、可溶性血浆蛋白、细胞表面受体以及脂质(特别是低密度脂蛋白(LDL)和高密度脂蛋白(HDL))[32., 33., 34.]。游离血红素的最终结合蛋白是血凝素(Hpx),其通过六配位复合物不可逆地结合血红素,阻断其氧化活性并将其递送至肝实质细胞进行降解[35]。血浆中存在几种血红素结合亲和力较低的中间载体蛋白,如白蛋白和α-1-微球蛋白(A1M)[36., 37., 38.],而分子量仅 27-kDa 的 A1M 同时也是重要的组织血红素结合蛋白[36]。当 Hpx 耗竭时(如镰状细胞病(SCD)患者),这些蛋白可能调节血红素在血浆与不同组织区室间的分布,并可能导致器官特异性毒性模式[39]。
One of the most identifiable end-products of heme release are oxidized LDLs and HDLs, oxLDL and oxHDL [16,40., 41., 42.]. Lipid oxidation is considered to be a critical event in the pathogenesis of endothelial dysfunction, progressive vasculopathy, and atherosclerosis in animals and humans [43,44]. Free heme has also been defined as an activator of innate immunity pathways in endothelial cells and leukocytes [45., 46., 47., 48., 49., 50.].
血红素释放最易识别的终产物之一是氧化型低密度脂蛋白(LDL)和高密度脂蛋白(HDL),即 oxLDL 与 oxHDL[16,40-42]。脂质氧化被认为是导致动物和人类内皮功能障碍、进行性血管病变及动脉粥样硬化发病机制中的关键事件[43,44]。游离血红素还被证实是内皮细胞和白细胞中天然免疫通路的激活剂[45-50]。

Adaptive and Physiological Effects
适应性与生理效应

The extravascular and intravascular processes of hemolysis are diverse and both macrophages and plasma demonstrate independent and integrated protective mechanisms of handling RBC degradation products and cell-free Hb (Figure 1A,B). In the circulation and within tissue compartments, hemolysis leads to free-Hb and its degradation products, heme and iron, in animal models and humans [39,51,52]. Both are toxins that contribute toward pathological modification of disease by their own unique mechanisms; however, similar to Hb and heme-specific binding proteins in plasma, specific receptor systems exist for clearance of the scavenger protein complexes from plasma and extravascular tissue sites by macrophages and other cell types (Figure 1A,B) [53., 54., 55.].
溶血的外血管和内血管过程具有多样性,巨噬细胞和血浆均展现出独立且协同的保护机制来处理红细胞降解产物和游离血红蛋白(图 1A,B)。在循环系统及组织间隙中,动物模型和人体研究表明溶血会导致游离血红蛋白及其降解产物(血红素和铁)的释放[39,51,52]。这两类物质均具有毒性,通过各自独特机制参与疾病的病理改变;然而类似于血浆中的血红蛋白和血红素特异性结合蛋白,巨噬细胞及其他细胞类型存在特定的受体系统,可清除血浆和外血管组织中的清道夫蛋白复合物(图 1A,B)[53., 54., 55.]。
Figure 1
  1. Download: Download high-res image (583KB)
    下载:下载高分辨率图片(583KB)
  2. Download: Download full-size image
    下载:下载完整尺寸图片

Figure 1. Red Blood Cell Damage, Hemoglobin (Hb) Toxicity and Protective Pathways.
图 1. 红细胞损伤、血红蛋白(Hb)毒性及保护性通路

By default, a damaged red blood cell is recognized and phagocytosed by macrophages. In the absence of sufficient erythrophagocytosis capacity (e.g., during severe acute or chronic hemolysis) or after physical damage to red blood cells, hemolysis occurs in the extracellular space releasing cell-free Hb. Hb and heme can be bound and detoxified by the plasma scavenger proteins haptoglobin (Hp) and hemopexin (Hpx), while iron released by the macrophage is bound to transferrin (A). Specific scavenger receptors mediate endocytosis of Hb–Hp (CD163) and heme– Hpx (CD91) complexes. Phagocytosed red blood cells and heme–protein complexes are degraded by the macrophage and heme is metabolized to bilirubin, carbon monoxide, and iron through heme/Bach1/Nrf2-mediated induction of heme-oxygenase 1 (HO-1). Iron is stored in a complex with ferritin or exported from macrophages by the iron-transporter ferroportin. In the extracellular space, iron is bound by transferrin and transported to hematopoietic tissues to support erythropoiesis. Intracellular signaling that accompanies erythrophagocytosis and heme metabolism promotes metabolic adaptation and modulates macrophages into a specific phenotype (erythrophagocyte) with anti-inflammatory and regenerative functions (B).
正常情况下,受损红细胞会被巨噬细胞识别并吞噬。当红细胞吞噬能力不足(如严重急性或慢性溶血时)或红细胞遭受物理损伤后,细胞外空间会发生溶血并释放游离血红蛋白。血浆清除蛋白结合珠蛋白(Hp)和血凝素(Hpx)可结合并解毒 Hb 和血红素,而巨噬细胞释放的铁则与转铁蛋白结合(A)。特异性清除受体介导 Hb-Hp 复合物(CD163)和血红素-Hpx 复合物(CD91)的内吞作用。被吞噬的红细胞和血红素-蛋白复合物由巨噬细胞降解,血红素通过血红素/Bach1/Nrf2 介导的血红素加氧酶 1(HO-1)诱导代谢为胆红素、一氧化碳和铁。铁以铁蛋白复合物形式储存,或通过铁转运蛋白膜铁转运蛋白从巨噬细胞输出。在细胞外空间,铁与转铁蛋白结合并被运输至造血组织以支持红细胞生成。 伴随红细胞吞噬和血红素代谢的细胞内信号传导促进代谢适应,并将巨噬细胞调控为具有抗炎与再生功能的特殊表型(红细胞吞噬细胞)(B)。
Hb and heme are known to trigger adaptive cellular responses that can be protective in certain tissues and during certain pathophysiological conditions (e.g., intraplaque hemorrhage with macrophage polarization toward increased Hb metabolism) [56., 57., 58., 59.]. Heme and other metal-porphyrins can selectively bind to several transcription factors, receptors, and enzymes and thereby alter gene transcription and cellular metabolism. The best defined interaction is the binding of heme to the transcriptional repressor Bach-1, which regulates heme-oxygenase 1 (HMOX) and other antioxidant and iron-metabolism genes essential for the adaptive response to enhanced intracellular heme levels [60,61]. Heme also activates liver-X-receptor (LXR)-coordinated gene expression in macrophages, which may support an anti-inflammatory macrophage phenotype (Mhem) [58,62]. In addition, under certain conditions heme is suggested to be a damage-associated molecular pattern and an agonist of the endotoxin receptor toll like receptor 4 (Tlr4) [47,49,50,63] and an inhibitor of the proteasome [64].
血红蛋白(Hb)和血红素已知能触发适应性细胞反应,这些反应在特定组织及某些病理生理条件下(如斑块内出血伴随巨噬细胞向增强 Hb 代谢方向极化)具有保护作用[56-59]。血红素及其他金属卟啉可选择性地与多种转录因子、受体和酶结合,从而改变基因转录及细胞代谢。其中最明确的相互作用是血红素与转录抑制因子 Bach-1 的结合,该因子调控血红素加氧酶 1(HMOX)及其他抗氧化和铁代谢基因,这些基因对细胞内血红素水平升高的适应性反应至关重要[60,61]。血红素还能激活巨噬细胞中肝脏 X 受体(LXR)协调的基因表达,这可能支持抗炎型巨噬细胞表型(Mhem)的形成[58,62]。此外,在某些条件下,血红素被认为是一种损伤相关分子模式,可作为内毒素受体 Toll 样受体 4(Tlr4)的激动剂[47,49,50,63]及蛋白酶体的抑制剂[64]。
Most critical to homeostasis of Hb, heme, and iron, and for the prevention of Hb-driven toxicity, are the three high-affinity binding and transport proteins that are abundant in plasma. These include haptoglobin, Hpx, and transferrin (ApoTf) [65,66]. Depending on the nature of the hemolytic condition, supplementation with these proteins as therapeutic agents may prove effective at controlling the acute and chronic disease-modifying effects of Hb and its degradation products [67., 68., 69., 70.]. Figure 1 illustrates the progression of RBC damage and intravascular hemolysis that results in Hb and heme release and transfer to haptoglobin and Hpx, respectively. Erythrophagocytosis of damaged or senescent RBCs by macrophages and the subsequent export of iron through ferroportin [71] leads to transferrin saturation and, eventually, non-transferrin bound iron and labile plasma iron [72,73]. From this graphical representation of hemolysis, we focus on the critical role of haptoglobin in the prevention of cell-free Hb exposure in the kidney, cardiovascular system, lung, and brain. Herein, we suggest and describe a mechanism of compartmentalization that underpins the potential therapeutic efficacy of haptoglobin as critical modifier of the downstream toxicological effects of intravascular and tissue hemolysis.
对于维持血红蛋白(Hb)、血红素和铁的稳态以及预防 Hb 介导的毒性作用最为关键的,是血浆中含量丰富的三种高亲和力结合转运蛋白:结合珠蛋白(haptoglobin)、血色素结合蛋白(Hpx)和转铁蛋白(ApoTf)[65,66]。根据溶血性疾病的性质,补充这些蛋白作为治疗剂可能有效控制 Hb 及其降解产物引发的急慢性疾病修饰效应[67-70]。图 1 展示了红细胞损伤与血管内溶血导致 Hb 和血红素释放,并分别转移至结合珠蛋白与血色素结合蛋白的过程。巨噬细胞对损伤或衰老红细胞的吞噬作用,以及随后通过膜铁转运蛋白输出的铁[71],将导致转铁蛋白饱和并最终形成非转铁蛋白结合铁和不稳定血浆铁[72,73]。基于该溶血过程的图示,我们重点探讨结合珠蛋白在防止肾脏、心血管系统、肺部和大脑接触游离 Hb 方面的关键作用。 本文提出并阐述了一种区室化机制,该机制是触珠蛋白作为血管内和组织溶血下游毒性效应关键调节剂发挥潜在治疗功效的基础。

The Significance of Cell-Free Hb and of Haptoglobin in Disease
游离血红蛋白与结合珠蛋白在疾病中的重要意义

Preclinical studies have focused on the role of haptoglobin supplementation therapy and the subsequent attenuation of hemodynamic instability and tissue injury following Hb exposure across a range of models with specific end-points [18., 19., 20.,67,74., 75., 76., 77., 78.]. Several critical organs, such as the kidneys, the cardiovascular system, lungs, liver, and brain are adversely affected following hemolysis. Hb release from RBCs into the blood plasma or into a closed compartment such as the CSF space dilutes the protein, favoring dissociation of the tetramers and endothelial barrier translocation (‘decompartmentalization’) of the small dimer molecules. This key process of Hb decompartmentalization is illustrated in representative images that summarize the primary role of haptoglobin in the mitigation of Hb-driven pathophysiology in the kidney (Figure 2), heart (Figure 3), and brain (Figure 4). In all these examples, tissue parenchymal deposition of Hb dimers is an important component of disease progression that can be specifically targeted by haptoglobin supplementation. The critical role of this compartmentalization effect of the Hb–haptoglobin complex is emphasized by the observation that haptoglobin binding does not change the NO reaction kinetics of Hb, which is identical in free Hb and in the complex [20,67]. In the following sections we have selected three representative conditions where hemolysis, Hb, and Hb degradation products are contributors to disease onset and/or progression. Within these conditions, significant efforts have been made to advance the understanding of Hb and haptoglobin balance/imbalance in human disease and in the development of preclinical proof-of-concept.
临床前研究重点关注了补充结合珠蛋白疗法的作用,以及随后在各种具有特定终点的模型中血红蛋白暴露后血流动力学不稳定和组织损伤的减轻[18., 19., 20.,67,74., 75., 76., 77., 78.]。溶血发生后,肾脏、心血管系统、肺、肝脏和大脑等多个关键器官会受到不利影响。红细胞释放到血浆或脑脊液等封闭腔室中的血红蛋白会稀释该蛋白,促使四聚体解离,并使小分子二聚体穿过内皮屏障("去区室化")。这一血红蛋白去区室化的关键过程通过代表性图像得以展示,这些图像总结了结合珠蛋白在减轻肾脏(图 2)、心脏(图 3)和大脑(图 4)中血红蛋白驱动病理生理变化中的主要作用。所有这些实例中,血红蛋白二聚体在组织实质中的沉积是疾病进展的重要组成部分,可通过补充结合珠蛋白进行特异性干预。 血红蛋白-触珠蛋白复合物的这种区室化效应的关键作用通过以下观察得到强调:触珠蛋白结合不会改变血红蛋白与一氧化氮的反应动力学,游离血红蛋白与复合物中的血红蛋白在此方面表现一致[20,67]。在后续章节中,我们选取了三种具有代表性的病理状态,其中溶血、血红蛋白及其降解产物是疾病发生和/或进展的促进因素。针对这些病理状态,学界已付出重大努力以深化对血红蛋白与触珠蛋白在人类疾病中平衡/失衡关系的理解,并推动临床前概念验证研究的发展。
Figure 2
  1. Download: Download high-res image (755KB)
    下载:下载高分辨率图片(755KB)
  2. Download: Download full-size image
    下载:下载全尺寸图片

Figure 2. Hemolysis, Hemoglobin (Hb) Compartmentalization, and Renal Injury.
图 2. 溶血、血红蛋白(Hb)区室化与肾损伤

In conditions of extensive intravascular hemolysis, such as hemolytic uremic syndrome, Hb dimers (red) are filtered by the glomerular membrane. This leads to hemoglobinuria with Hb-, heme-, and iron deposition in tubules and epithelial cells, which can be observed as a ruddy brown discoloration of the kidney shown on the inset photo image on the right side. This organ was collected from a guinea pig after toxin-induced severe hemolytic uremic syndrome. Occasionally, hemoglobinuria can cause tubule damage, acute kidney injury, or more severe renal failure requiring renal replacement therapy. Haptoglobin (Hp) administration compartmentalizes Hb within the intravascular space, preventing Hb filtration, hemoglobinuria, and renal injury. Parts of this figure have been adapted from [21,74].
在广泛血管内溶血的情况下(如溶血性尿毒症综合征),血红蛋白二聚体(红色)会被肾小球膜过滤。这导致血红蛋白尿,并伴有 Hb、血红素和铁在肾小管及上皮细胞中的沉积,如右侧插图照片所示肾脏呈现红棕色改变。该器官采集自毒素诱导严重溶血性尿毒症综合征后的豚鼠。血红蛋白尿有时可导致肾小管损伤、急性肾损伤或需要肾脏替代治疗的更严重肾衰竭。给予结合珠蛋白(Hp)可将 Hb 限制在血管内空间,防止 Hb 过滤、血红蛋白尿及肾损伤。本图部分内容改编自[21,74]。
Figure 3
  1. Download: Download high-res image (753KB)
    下载:下载高分辨率图片(753KB)
  2. Download: Download full-size image
    下载:下载全尺寸图片

Figure 3. Hemoglobin (Hb) Tissue Translocation and Compartmentalization in the Heart.
图 3. 血红蛋白(Hb)在心脏中的组织转位与区室化

(A,B) Depict the cross-section of a coronary artery, with the inner tunica intima and lamina elastica interna (dark gray), followed by the tunica media harboring smooth muscle cells (gray) separated by the interstitial space (blank), and wrapped by the outer tunica adventitia. (B,C) Depict the myocardial muscle with myocytes (faint brown) and the interstitial space (gray). After intravascular exposure to cell-free Hb (red), the protein can be detected within minutes in the interstitial space of the vascular smooth muscle cell layer of coronary arteries (A) and in all of the interstitial space of the myocardium (C). The functional effect of this Hb delocalization is defined by its nitric oxide reactions, which deplete the vasodilator, causing an acute vasoconstriction and myocardial ischemia. Administration of haptoglobin (Hp) (B,D) compartmentalizes Hb dimers (red) in the intravascular compartment, as indicated by the Hb-filled capillaries in the myocardium, while the interstitial space (gray) is devoid of Hb signal (D). This effect of haptoglobin prevents tissue translocation, vasoconstriction, and disruption in perfusion-mediated oxygen delivery. Parts of this figure have been adapted from [19].
(A、B)展示冠状动脉横截面,由内至外依次为内膜层与内弹性膜(深灰色)、中膜层含平滑肌细胞(灰色)并由间质间隙(空白)分隔,最外层为外膜层包裹。(B、C)显示心肌组织,其中肌细胞呈浅棕色,间质间隙为灰色。血管内暴露于游离血红蛋白(红色)后,数分钟内即可在冠状动脉血管平滑肌细胞层的间质间隙(A)及心肌全部间质区域(C)检测到该蛋白。这种血红蛋白异位分布的功能效应通过其一氧化氮反应体现:消耗血管舒张因子导致急性血管收缩和心肌缺血。注射结合珠蛋白(Hp)(B、D)可将血红蛋白二聚体(红色)限制在血管内区间,如心肌中充满血红蛋白的毛细血管所示,而间质间隙(灰色)无血红蛋白信号(D)。结合珠蛋白的这一作用能阻止组织移位、血管收缩及灌注介导的氧输送紊乱。 本图部分内容改编自[19]。
Figure 4
  1. Download: Download high-res image (1MB)
    下载:下载高分辨率图像(1MB)
  2. Download: Download full-size image
    下载:下载全尺寸图片

Figure 4. Red Blood Cell Lysis and Delayed Neurological Damage after Subarachnoid Hemorrhage (SAH).
图 4. 蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)后的红细胞溶解与迟发性神经损伤

After SAH, cell-free hemoglobin (Hb) (red) is slowly released from lysing erythrocytes in the subarachnoid blood clot, leading to a progressive Hb accumulation in the cerebrospinal fluid over days following arterial injury and clot formation. The cell-free Hb distributes along the perivascular cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) spaces (Virchow-Robin space) and across the glia limitans (which is formed as a CSF–brain barrier by astrocyte foot processes) deep into the brain (A). A second delocalization pathway extends from the CSF into the vascular smooth muscle cell layer (green) of cerebral arteries. In this site, cell-free Hb reacts with nitric oxide and causes vasospasm of large and small cerebral arteries. Haptoglobin (Hp) compartmentalizes Hb in the cerebrovascular fluid compartment, preventing tissue delocalization and vasospasm (B). Secondary toxicities of tissue-delocalized Hb, such as cortical spreading depolarizations, may be caused by oxidative damage and nitric oxide neurotransmitter depletion in the brain interstitial microenvironment. Parts of this figure have been adapted from [20]. Abbreviation: aSMA, alpha-Smooth Muscle Actin.
蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)后,游离血红蛋白(Hb)(红色)从蛛网膜下腔血凝块中溶解的红细胞缓慢释放,导致动脉损伤和血凝块形成后数日内脑脊液中 Hb 逐渐积累。游离 Hb 沿血管周围脑脊液(CSF)间隙(Virchow-Robin 间隙)分布,并穿过由星形胶质细胞足突形成的 CSF-脑屏障(胶质界膜)深入脑组织(A)。第二条迁移路径从 CSF 延伸至脑血管平滑肌细胞层(绿色)。在此部位,游离 Hb 与一氧化氮反应并引发大小脑动脉血管痉挛。结合珠蛋白(Hp)将 Hb 隔离在脑血管液腔室内,防止组织迁移和血管痉挛(B)。组织迁移 Hb 的继发毒性(如皮层扩散性抑制)可能是由脑间质微环境中的氧化损伤和一氧化氮神经递质耗竭引起的。本图部分内容改编自[20]。缩写:aSMA,α-平滑肌肌动蛋白。
Download: Download video (58MB)

Figure360: An Author Presentation of Figure 4..

Sickle Cell Anemia  镰状细胞贫血

SCD is a genetic hemolytic anemia with multiple contributing comorbidities and each is affected by numerous molecular and biochemical changes. SCD originates from a mutation in the beta-Hb gene on chromosome 11 (11p15.1) that is characterized by a genotype-CAG codon to GTG. A glutamic acid replacing valine at the sixth amino acid position within the Hb beta chain leads to the sickle cell phenotype (HbS) [79]. This seemingly minor modification facilitates the polymerization of Hb during tense state (T-deoxyHb) to relaxed state (R-oxyHb) transitioning, which promotes ‘sickling’ morphological changes and, ultimately, hemolysis of erythrocytes [80,81]. As a result, drug development efforts have targeted antipolymerization strategies to dilute intraerythrocytic HbS by increasing fetal Hb with oral hydroxyurea therapy [82,83] and to increase Hb oxygen affinity [84., 85., 86., 87.], using curative efforts such as gene therapy [88., 89., 90.], as well as comprehensive strategies to address the acute and chronic progressive debilitating sequelae of SCD [91].
镰状细胞病(SCD)是一种遗传性溶血性贫血,伴随多种共病状态,每种并发症均受众多分子与生化改变的影响。该病源于 11 号染色体(11p15.1)β-血红蛋白基因突变,其特征为 CAG 密码子被 GTG 取代。血红蛋白β链第六位氨基酸的谷氨酸被缬氨酸替代,导致镰状血红蛋白(HbS)表型的形成[79]。这一看似微小的修饰促进了血红蛋白在紧张态(T-脱氧 Hb)向松弛态(R-氧合 Hb)转换过程中的聚合,从而引发红细胞"镰变"形态学改变并最终导致溶血[80,81]。因此,药物研发主要针对以下策略:通过羟基脲口服疗法增加胎儿血红蛋白以稀释红细胞内 HbS 的抗聚合策略[82,83];提高血红蛋白氧亲和力[84-87];采用基因治疗等根治性手段[88-90];以及针对 SCD 急慢性进行性衰弱后遗症的综合治疗策略[91]。
Human SCD patients experience a range of end organ damage that results in whole body pathophysiology [92., 93., 94., 95., 96., 97., 98., 99., 100., 101.]. The end organ complications associated with SCD are multifactorial and the impact of free Hb and its metabolic end-products on disease progression have been debated extensively [102., 103., 104., 105., 106.]. Preclinical proof-of-concept studies have focused on the use of haptoglobin in SCD animal models to prevent end organ injury specific to the vasculature, kidneys, and lungs. In these studies, haptoglobin administration seems to attenuate disease progression in both acute and subchronic settings. Acute studies with haptoglobin therapy suggest potential utility in reducing vascular injury and vaso-occlusive crisis in murine SCD [107,108]. Similarly, haptoglobin dosing in subchronic settings suggests reduction of renal tubule Hb accumulation [109], with no demonstrable improvement in overall kidney function [110]. Human SCD with pulmonary hypertension and lung injury appears to be influenced by Hb, hypoxia, and, subsequently, macrophage reprogramming consistent with both stressors [111]. A rat model designed to mimic the effects of hypoxia and Hb on pulmonary hypertension and right heart failure suggests that progression of pulmonary vascular remodeling and right heart dysfunction are attenuated by haptoglobin dosing, administered multiple times per week [76]. Within these organ systems (i.e., vasculature, kidney, and lung), evidence is emerging that haptoglobin has a positive therapeutic effect in preclinical models of SCD.
镰状细胞病(SCD)患者会出现一系列终末器官损伤,导致全身性病理生理变化[92-101]。与 SCD 相关的终末器官并发症具有多因素性,游离血红蛋白及其代谢终产物对疾病进展的影响一直存在广泛争议[102-106]。临床前概念验证研究主要聚焦于在 SCD 动物模型中使用结合珠蛋白(haptoglobin)预防特定血管系统、肾脏和肺部的终末器官损伤。这些研究表明,无论是急性还是亚慢性状态下,给予结合珠蛋白都能延缓疾病进展。急性期结合珠蛋白治疗研究显示,该疗法可能有助于减轻小鼠 SCD 模型的血管损伤和血管阻塞危象[107,108];而在亚慢性给药方案中,结合珠蛋白显示出减少肾小管血红蛋白积聚的作用[109],但未观察到整体肾功能改善[110]。人类 SCD 合并肺动脉高压和肺损伤的病理过程似乎受到血红蛋白、低氧以及随之发生的巨噬细胞重编程(与上述双重应激因素相关)的共同影响[111]。 一项旨在模拟缺氧和血红蛋白对肺动脉高压及右心衰竭影响的大鼠模型研究表明,每周多次给予结合珠蛋白治疗可减轻肺血管重塑进展和右心功能障碍[76]。在这些器官系统(即脉管系统、肾脏和肺部)中,越来越多的证据表明结合珠蛋白在镰状细胞病的临床前模型中具有积极治疗效果。

Sepsis and RBC Transfusion
脓毒症与红细胞输注

During sepsis, significant changes in RBC morphology [112], oxidative stress [113], oxygen delivery [114], and circulatory clearance [115] have been reported. Consistent with a process of sepsis-induced hemolysis, plasma levels of cell-free Hb are increased in patients with sepsis [116] and higher plasma concentrations of cell-free Hb coincided with higher mortality [117]. Accordingly, plasma concentrations of haptoglobin and Hpx are often depleted [118], while transferrin saturations are generally increased [119] in critically ill septic patients. Plasma Hb levels in these studies were consistent with a mild hemolysis (10–40 mg/dl, or ~5–25 μM heme in plasma). Sepsis with concomitant transfusion of RBCs increases hemolysis and exposures to cell-free Hb [120,121] and its degradation products, heme [122] and iron [123,124], in experimental models and clinical disease [125,126]. However, the true contribution of hemolysis and cell-free Hb ‘toxicity’ toward end organ injury in sepsis is not fully understood.
脓毒症期间,已报道红细胞形态[112]、氧化应激[113]、氧输送[114]和循环清除率[115]发生显著变化。与脓毒症诱导的溶血过程一致,脓毒症患者血浆中游离血红蛋白水平升高[116],且较高浓度的血浆游离血红蛋白与更高死亡率相关[117]。相应地,危重脓毒症患者的结合珠蛋白和血凝素血浆浓度常出现耗竭[118],而转铁蛋白饱和度通常升高[119]。这些研究中的血浆血红蛋白水平符合轻度溶血特征(10-40 mg/dl,或约 5-25 μM 血浆血红素)。在实验模型和临床疾病中[125,126],脓毒症伴随红细胞输注会加剧溶血,增加游离血红蛋白[120,121]及其降解产物血红素[122]和铁[123,124]的暴露。然而,溶血和游离血红蛋白"毒性"对脓毒症终末器官损伤的真实作用机制尚未完全阐明。
Animal models of endotoxemia and sepsis have been evaluated to assess the contributions of cell-free Hb to acute kidney injury [67,127,128], acute lung injury (ALI), and acute respiratory distress syndrome [129], as well as to cardiac injury [75]. The primary studies that have developed proof-of-concept understanding on the feasibility of haptoglobin administration in sepsis were conducted with concomitant Hb exposure or blood transfusion. Haptoglobin administration was evaluated in sepsis-free animal models with extensive Hb exposure following transfusion of poor quality RBCs. In these studies, haptoglobin attenuated the deleterious effects of Hb and its degradation products on the kidneys and the vasculature [68,74,77]. Haptoglobin also attenuated lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-enhanced Hb cardiomyocyte toxicity in a guinea pig model of endotoxemia, [75] which supports data that LPS increases Hb-mediated end organ injury as well as mortality in sepsis animal models [130., 131., 132.]. These observations are also consistent with lung injury and mortality endpoint studies in septic dogs, where both ALI and survival were improved following haptoglobin administration in the absence and in the presence of concomitant RBC transfusion [133]. Nonetheless, sepsis remains a complex indication and a challenge for therapeutic development. For example, interpretation of human dosing from animal studies is not accurate, because clearance mechanisms in humans differ from species commonly used in preclinical studies [134., 135., 136.]. Further, some bacterial pathogens express receptors that bind Hb–haptoglobin complexes in their efforts to obtain iron for nutrient metabolism, which may impact safety and efficacy of a haptoglobin therapy in human infection, depending on the bacterial strain and its adaptation to acquisition of Hb-derived iron sources [137].
已通过内毒素血症和脓毒症动物模型评估了游离血红蛋白对急性肾损伤[67,127,128]、急性肺损伤(ALI)及急性呼吸窘迫综合征[129]以及心脏损伤[75]的作用机制。关于结合珠蛋白在脓毒症中应用可行性的概念验证研究,主要在同时存在血红蛋白暴露或输血条件下开展。研究人员还在无脓毒症的动物模型中评估了结合珠蛋白的疗效,这些模型通过输注劣质红细胞造成大量血红蛋白暴露。研究表明,结合珠蛋白能有效减轻血红蛋白及其降解产物对肾脏和血管系统的损害[68,74,77]。 在豚鼠内毒素血症模型中,结合珠蛋白同样减轻了脂多糖(LPS)增强的血红蛋白心肌细胞毒性[75],该结果支持了 LPS 会增加血红蛋白介导的终末器官损伤及脓毒症动物模型死亡率的数据[130-132]。这些观察结果也与脓毒症犬的肺损伤和死亡率终点研究一致——无论是否伴随红细胞输注,给予结合珠蛋白后均能改善急性肺损伤(ALI)和生存率[133]。然而脓毒症仍是治疗开发的复杂适应症和重大挑战。例如,从动物研究推算人类给药剂量并不准确,因为人体的清除机制与临床前研究常用物种存在差异[134-136]。此外,某些细菌病原体为获取铁营养代谢会表达结合血红蛋白-结合珠蛋白复合物的受体,这可能影响结合珠蛋白疗法在人类感染中的安全性和有效性,具体取决于细菌菌株及其对血红蛋白来源铁获取的适应能力[137]。

SAH  蛛网膜下腔出血

SAH typically results from an aneurysmal malformation of a large cerebral artery. This type of intracranial bleeding accounts for 5–10% of all strokes in the USA [138]. The loss of productive life years due to aneurysmal SAH (aSAH) is similar to the cumulative morbidity caused by cerebral infarction, since it often affects patients younger than 65 years of age [139]. A major contributor to poor outcome in patients with SAH is delayed ischemia with secondary brain damage and irreversible neurological deficit [140]. This complication occurs between 4 and 14 days after SAH and is caused by transient deficits in brain perfusion. This hypoperfusion is caused in part by vasospasm of large cerebral arteries and by a dysregulated microcirculation resulting from small vessel vasoconstriction or thrombotic occlusion [141]. The pathophysiology of delayed ischemia is complex, multifactorial, and incompletely understood. However, lysis of RBC and release of cell-free Hb into the subarachnoid space have been suspected as potential drivers of delayed neurological damage for decades [142]. A recent study demonstrated that injection of cell-free Hb into the subarachnoid space of sheep was sufficient to cause severe spasm of all major cerebral arteries, as well as of small arteries within the brain parenchyma [20]. These effects of Hb were correlated with the delocalization of Hb deep into the neuronal brain tissue and into the interstitial space compartment of the arterial vascular smooth muscle layer of cerebral arteries. Haptoglobin completely blocked this cell-free Hb delocalization from the CSF compartment into the brain parenchyma and the NO-sensitive compartments of cerebral arteries. This confinement of cell-free Hb within the CSF prevented spasm of large and small cerebral arteries and it may also protect susceptible neuronal structures and microglia against oxidative and proinflammatory effects of cell-free Hb. The protective activity of haptoglobin was reproducible in an ex vivo model of basilar artery vasospasm that was induced by exposure of porcine basilar arteries to Hb-rich CSF collected from patients with delayed ischemia after an aSAH [20]. Also in the CSF environment, haptoglobin did not alter the NO reaction kinetics of bound Hb, reinforcing the exclusion of NO-reactive Hb from NO-sensitive tissue compartments as the primary mechanism of protection. In a mouse model, haptoglobin was also effective in restricting brain parenchymal delocalization and mitigating neuronal toxicity that was induced by continuous intrathecal administration of cell-free Hb for 2 weeks [143].
蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)通常由大脑动脉瘤性血管畸形导致。此类颅内出血占美国所有脑卒中病例的 5%-10%[138]。由于动脉瘤性 SAH(aSAH)好发于 65 岁以下患者,其造成的有效生命年损失与脑梗死累积发病率相当[139]。SAH 患者预后不良的主要原因是迟发性脑缺血引发的继发性脑损伤及不可逆神经功能缺损[140]。该并发症发生于 SAH 后 4-14 天,由脑灌注短暂性不足引起。这种低灌注部分源于大脑血管痉挛,以及小血管收缩或血栓性闭塞导致的微循环失调[141]。迟发性缺血的病理生理机制复杂多元,目前尚未完全阐明。但数十年来,红细胞溶解导致游离血红蛋白释放至蛛网膜下腔,始终被视为迟发性神经损伤的潜在驱动因素[142]。 最近一项研究表明,将游离血红蛋白注射入绵羊蛛网膜下腔足以引发所有主要脑动脉及脑实质内小动脉的严重痉挛[20]。血红蛋白的这些效应与其向神经元脑组织深部及脑动脉血管平滑肌层间质空间的迁移密切相关。触珠蛋白能完全阻断游离血红蛋白从脑脊液腔室向脑实质及脑动脉一氧化氮敏感区域的迁移。将游离血红蛋白限制在脑脊液腔内可预防大小脑动脉痉挛,同时可能保护易损神经元结构和微胶质细胞免受游离血红蛋白的氧化及促炎作用。触珠蛋白的保护作用在基底动脉血管痉挛的离体模型中得到重现,该模型通过将猪基底动脉暴露于 aSAH 后迟发性脑缺血患者富含血红蛋白的脑脊液而诱导产生[20]。 同样在脑脊液环境中,结合珠蛋白并未改变与血红蛋白结合的 NO 反应动力学,这进一步证实了其保护机制主要是将具有 NO 反应活性的血红蛋白隔离于 NO 敏感组织区室之外。在小鼠模型中,持续两周鞘内注射游离血红蛋白诱导的脑实质扩散和神经元毒性,结合珠蛋白也能有效限制其扩散并减轻毒性作用[143]。
In patients with aSAH, the haptoglobin concentrations in CSF are orders of magnitudes below the cell-free Hb concentrations that accumulate within a few days after the initial bleeding [144]. However, because hemolysis in the subarachnoid space occurs with a delay of several days after the bleeding event [145], it may be possible to administer enough purified or recombinant haptoglobin into the CSF compartment via a ventricular drainage catheter to supplement sufficient Hb scavenger capacity to prevent Hb-driven complications.
在动脉瘤性蛛网膜下腔出血(aSAH)患者中,脑脊液(CSF)中的结合珠蛋白浓度比出血后数日内积累的游离血红蛋白浓度低数个数量级[144]。然而,由于蛛网膜下腔的溶血现象在出血事件后数日才会延迟发生[145],因此有可能通过脑室引流导管向 CSF 腔隙内输注足量纯化或重组结合珠蛋白,以补充足够的血红蛋白清除能力,从而预防血红蛋白驱动的并发症。

Concluding Remarks  结论性评述

Hb is one of the most abundant proteins in the human body. Under physiological conditions, compartmentalization and antioxidant control of the chemical reactivity of Hb within the RBC provides protection against Hb- and heme-driven adverse physiology. Increasing evidence accumulated over the last decade suggests that cell-free Hb is an important and ubiquitous driver of adverse disease processes. The observations that tissue-translocation of Hb-dimers remain the key initiation step of Hb toxicity, and the discovery that administration of haptoglobin can reverse this toxicity-pathway through compartmentalization of cell-free Hb, is novel. This concept broadens the therapeutic possibilities for haptoglobin beyond that of hemolysis within the circulation and opens several doors of opportunity for diseases where lysis of RBC occurs in closed space compartments. Examples of these include spinal cord bleeding, intraocular hemorrhages, and traumatic brain injury with microvascular bleeding and all introduce new challenges to preventing secondary pathophysiologies caused by Hb. Here we present one such possibility, where Hb enters the brain vascular and parenchymal compartments by an outside-to-inside phenomenon that may result in secondary blood vessel constriction and tissue parenchymal injury following aSAH. Furthermore, treatment with haptoglobin in this, and potentially other indications, could forge new pathways into advancing regulatory and approval processes for novel and needed biologic therapeutics, cell-based therapies, and their delivery system devices targeting sites within the central nervous system.
血红蛋白(Hb)是人体内含量最丰富的蛋白质之一。在生理条件下,红细胞内血红蛋白化学活性的区室化作用及抗氧化调控机制可有效防止血红蛋白和血红素引发的病理生理反应。过去十年积累的越来越多的证据表明,游离血红蛋白是驱动多种疾病恶化的重要且普遍存在的因素。研究发现血红蛋白二聚体的组织迁移仍是其毒性的关键起始步骤,而通过施用结合珠蛋白(haptoglobin)实现游离血红蛋白区室化可逆转这一毒性通路,这一发现具有创新性。该理论拓展了结合珠蛋白的临床应用前景,使其不再局限于循环系统中的溶血治疗,为红细胞在密闭腔室(如脊髓出血、眼内出血及伴有微血管出血的创伤性脑损伤等)发生溶解的疾病提供了多种治疗可能。这些情况都对预防血红蛋白引发的继发性病理生理过程提出了新的挑战。 在此,我们提出一种可能性:血红蛋白通过由外向内现象进入脑血管和实质组织区室,可能导致动脉瘤性蛛网膜下腔出血后继发性血管收缩及组织实质损伤。此外,应用结合珠蛋白治疗此类适应症(及其他潜在适应症)可为新型生物制剂、细胞疗法及其针对中枢神经系统靶点的递送系统装置开辟新的监管审批路径,推动这些亟需疗法的临床转化进程。
Here we present concepts of haptoglobin replacement at supraphysiologic levels based on its isolation from plasma. Nonetheless, these concepts are largely in their initial stages with regard to protein therapeutics development (see Outstanding Questions). In the future we envision moving toward highly novel therapeutics based on haptoglobin as a model protein for the binding and clearance of free Hb. The numerous advancements in recombinant protein design, truncated binding constructs, and fusion protein design are directly applicable to advancing the concepts of neutralizing Hb and its degradation toxins, heme and iron. Taken together, our current knowledge has advanced the understanding of haptoglobin function and disease modification. Future work should focus on optimization of scavenger protein therapeutics to address the totality of hemolysis-derived toxins in a disease state-specific strategy.
本文提出了基于血浆分离技术实现超生理水平结合珠蛋白替代治疗的理念。然而从蛋白质药物开发角度来看(参见"待解决问题"部分),这些理念仍处于初步探索阶段。我们展望未来将基于结合珠蛋白这一游离血红蛋白结合清除的模型蛋白,开发出高度创新的治疗手段。重组蛋白设计、截短型结合结构域构建以及融合蛋白设计等多项技术进步,均可直接应用于中和血红蛋白及其降解毒素(血红素与铁离子)的相关理念。现有研究已深化了对结合珠蛋白功能及疾病修饰作用的认识。未来工作应着重优化清道夫蛋白疗法,针对特定疾病状态全面清除溶血源性毒素。
Clinician’s Corner  临床医生专栏
Red blood cell damage leading to hemolysis is a process that accompanies many disease states. Primary hemolytic diseases include genetic hemolysis such as sickle cell disease, spherocytosis, or glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency. Mild to moderate systemic hemolysis is also a frequent secondary disease process in sepsis, transfusion, after burn injury, or in patients on extracorporeal circulation during heart surgery or in the intensive care unit (e.g., use of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation). Local hemolysis also occurs in confined spaces after localized bleeding, for example, after subarachnoid hemorrhage in the cerebrospinal fluid compartment.
红细胞损伤导致的溶血是伴随多种疾病状态的过程。原发性溶血性疾病包括遗传性溶血如镰状细胞贫血、球形红细胞增多症或葡萄糖-6-磷酸脱氢酶缺乏症。轻度至中度全身性溶血也常见于脓毒症、输血、烧伤后或心脏手术期间接受体外循环(如使用体外膜肺氧合)的重症监护患者中。局部溶血还可发生于局限性出血后的封闭空间内,例如蛛网膜下腔出血后的脑脊液腔室。
The common outcome of hemolysis is the release of Hb into the extracellular space. Subsequent translocation of cell-free Hb into vulnerable tissues initiates a cascade of ‘toxic’ adverse pathophysiological reactions that include depletion of the vasodilator nitric oxide (NO) and oxidation.
溶血通常导致血红蛋白释放至细胞外空间。游离血红蛋白随后易位进入脆弱组织,引发一系列"毒性"不良病理生理反应,包括血管舒张剂一氧化氮(NO)的耗竭和氧化反应。
Depending on the site, extent, and duration of hemolysis, the NO depletion and oxidative reactions of Hb in tissues may cause vasoconstriction with pulmonary and systemic hypertension, vaso-occlusion with ischemia, cerebral vasospasm, renal failure, and oxidative tissue damage.
根据溶血发生的部位、范围和持续时间,血红蛋白在组织中的一氧化氮耗竭和氧化反应可能导致血管收缩伴随肺性和全身性高血压、血管闭塞引发缺血、脑血管痉挛、肾功能衰竭以及氧化性组织损伤。
The Hb-binding protein haptoglobin is a potent antagonist of Hb toxicity. In preclinical animal models, supplementation of purified haptoglobin at supraphysiological concentrations proved to prevent hemolysis-induced renal failure, hypertension, and cerebral vasospasm. The key protective mechanism of haptoglobin in these models was the restriction of tissue barrier translocation by the large Hb–haptoglobin complex, which reduced toxic Hb exposures.
血红蛋白结合蛋白触珠蛋白是血红蛋白毒性的强效拮抗剂。在临床前动物模型中,补充超生理浓度的纯化触珠蛋白被证实可预防溶血引发的肾功能衰竭、高血压及脑血管痉挛。这些模型中触珠蛋白的关键保护机制在于:大分子血红蛋白-触珠蛋白复合物能限制组织屏障的跨膜转运,从而降低毒性血红蛋白的暴露水平。
The concept of Hb compartmentalization by plasma-derived or recombinant haptoglobin compiles an attractive path for new drug development in various fields with high unmet medical need, such as in sickle cell disease, sepsis, or hemorrhagic stroke.
血浆来源或重组结合珠蛋白对血红蛋白的区室化作用概念,为镰状细胞病、脓毒症和出血性中风等高未满足医疗需求领域的新药开发开辟了一条极具吸引力的路径。
Outstanding Questions  亟待解决的问题
What are the most relevant and realistic clinical indications for haptoglobin as a therapeutic protein?
作为治疗性蛋白,结合珠蛋白最相关且最现实的临床适应症有哪些?
Do current animal proof-of-concept studies provide translatable data to assess the potential for human response in complex disease states?
目前的动物概念验证研究是否能提供可转化的数据,以评估复杂疾病状态下人体潜在反应的可能性?
How will preclinical dose-dependent safety best be determined for atypical routes of administration (e.g., intracerebroventricular administration in patients after subarachnoid hemorrhage)?
对于非典型给药途径(例如蛛网膜下腔出血患者的脑室内给药),如何最佳确定临床前剂量依赖性安全性?
What are potential off-target effects of supraphysiological haptoglobin dosing and circulating Hb–haptoglobin complexes on immune function and iron sequestration-driven bacterial virulence responses?
超生理剂量触珠蛋白给药及循环中血红蛋白-触珠蛋白复合物可能对免疫功能及铁隔离驱动的细菌毒力反应产生哪些脱靶效应?
Does administration of plasma-derived or recombinant haptoglobin dimers (Hp 1-1) or multimers (2-1 and 2-2) impart differential therapeutic effects in hemolytic disease?
血浆来源或重组结合珠蛋白二聚体(Hp 1-1)与多聚体(2-1 和 2-2)的给药是否会在溶血性疾病中产生差异化的治疗效果?
Would protein reengineering of haptoglobin to design multifunctional (e.g., combinations of hemoglobin, heme, and iron-binding activity) binding proteins result in a more efficient approach to hemolysis detoxification based on the multicomponent toxins that arise from free hemoglobin?
对结合珠蛋白进行蛋白质重设计以构建多功能(如兼具血红蛋白、血红素和铁结合活性)结合蛋白,能否基于游离血红蛋白产生的多组分毒素,形成更高效的溶血解毒方法?
How are pharmacokinetic parameters and clearance pathways of Hb–haptoglobin complexes altered in hemolytic disease?
在溶血性疾病中,血红蛋白-触珠蛋白复合物的药代动力学参数及清除途径如何发生改变?
By what mechanisms and routes are therapeutic haptoglobin and in vivo-formed Hb–haptoglobin complexes cleared from confined compartments such as the subarachnoid space?
治疗性结合珠蛋白及体内形成的血红蛋白-结合珠蛋白复合物通过何种机制和途径从蛛网膜下腔等封闭腔隙中被清除?

Disclaimer Statement  免责声明

D.J.S. is an inventor on a patent application for the use of haptoglobin in subarachnoid hemorrhage. P.W.B. is a consultant to KaloCyte Inc. R.H. declares no conflicts of interest.
D.J.S. 是一项关于珠蛋白在蛛网膜下腔出血中应用的专利申请的发明人。P.W.B. 担任 KaloCyte 公司的顾问。R.H. 声明无利益冲突。

References

Cited by (64)

View all citing articles on Scopus

Glossary

Cerebral vasospasm
a pathological contraction of a cerebral artery, which can lead to cerebral ischemia and stroke.
Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy
a method for studying chemical species with unpaired electrons, such as in metal complexes or organic radicals. EPR can be adapted to the measurement of pO2 or O2 imaging in tissue with administration or implantation of paramagnetic molecules.
Endotoxemia
presence of endotoxins such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in the blood.
Sepsis
a potentially life-threatening syndrome caused by the inflammatory host response to infection.
Sickle cell disease (SCD)
a genetic disorder involving a single amino acid mutation, leading to hemoglobin polymerization, red blood cell ‘sickling’, and multiorgan injury that can be impacted by Hb and heme.
Stopped-flow spectrophotometry
a method of spectrophotometry that allows rapid kinetic measurements (in the millisecond range).
Subarachnoid space
the cerebrospinal fluid-filled space between the skull and the brain, defined by the arachnoid membrane facing the skull and the pia mater facing the brain.
Tense (T-deoxyHb) to relaxed state (R-oxyHb)
hemoglobin exists in two conformational states with higher affinity for oxygen [R-state (relaxed, oxyhemoglobin)], and lower affinity for oxygen [T-state (tense, deoxyhemoglobin)].
View Abstract